Dads Against the Divorce Industry

DA*DI is devoted to reinstating the societal valuation of Marriage and the traditional, nuclear American Family, with particular emphasis on the essential role of FATHERS.

DA*DI offers contemporary reports and commentary on culture; its aberrations and its heroes.



"Letters From A Killer"

Download the 340kb
VAWA.AVI file

Hazing could affect college plans

May 13, 2003

BY DEBRA PICKETT Staff Reporter

Students disciplined in the violent melee involving Glenbrook North High School students might be facing more than just an ugly end to their high school days. Their college careers might also be on the line.

Senior girls suspended, could get expelled

BY JANET RAUSA FULLER Staff Reporter

Citing the "devastating" impact of last week's violent hazing episode on the school and its students, Glenbrook North High School announced Monday the suspensions--and possible expulsions--of students who took part in an incident that has thrust the well-heeled north suburban school into the international spotlight.

Principal Mike Riggle said the students, all seniors, have been suspended for 10 days--the maximum allowed by state law--for breaking school conduct rules and public laws against hazing and assault and battery.

The school will recommend to the Northfield Township District 225 Board that the students be expelled, Riggle said. He refused to say how many students have been suspended. Junior girls hurt in the hazing could face similar punishment, Riggle said.

Seniors learned of their suspensions in meetings at school and were escorted from the building.

Sophomore Brittney Scala, who saw two girls being escorted out in tears, said she has little sympathy for them and others involved.

"Everyone's disappointed in them," Scala, 16, said. "No one wants to have anything to do with them."

The May 4 hazing at Chipilly Woods in Northbrook--which some students videotaped and photographed--was an annual initiation of junior girls at the hands of senior girls, who beat them and covered them with paint, mud, excrement and other substances. Five girls wound up in the hospital with injuries.

One student defended his sister who was suspended. "They didn't do anything wrong . . . [the junior girls] signed up for this," he said.

Craig Yudell of Northbrook, father of 18-year-old Valerie, a suspended student, said his daughter told him there were as many as 50 students punished. Officials would not confirm that figure.

Valerie has been accepted at Western Illinois University, he said. But Yudell was concerned the suspension would harm her future.

"They made one mistake, and you're punishing them for the rest of their lives," he told school board members and about 40 observers at a meeting Monday night.

He acknowledged Valerie was involved in the hazing, but, "She was in none of the swinging or hitting or anything like that."

When asked if Valerie should apologize for what happened, Yudell said, "She should. She apologized [at school] to a couple of girls who were there."

Some other parents said the off-campus incident was not a school concern, but school officials argued it is their concern because students involved have been identified as Glenbrook North students and because "some of the communications about the event took place at school," Riggle said.

Meanwhile, an 18-year-old senior girl filed a lawsuit Monday, hours after finding out she had been suspended. Marnie Holz is suing the school because she will miss a cram session for an advanced placement course in psychology. She can still take the AP course test at Glenbrook South.

The suspensions are a reversal of the school's position, which last week was confined to restricting students' participation in extracurricular activities because the event took place off campus.

After meeting with attorneys, school officials found they could take academic disciplinary action, Riggle said. He said those suspended broke school rules against hazing and harassment as well as Illinois School Code rules prohibiting membership in "any public school fraternity, sorority or secret society."

Students can appeal their suspensions or expulsions to "hearing officers" who will review the cases and report to the school board. The board has final say in expulsions.

Expelled seniors would not be allowed to attend graduation ceremonies. But they would still be able to get their Glenbrook North diploma through "alternative educational services," Riggle said.

The lawsuit by the suspended student, however, argues that the suspension means Marnie would miss exams and quizzes, a review for her physics final and rack up 10 unexcused absences, which "would significantly lower her grade."

Leslie Holz said her daughter was at the event, but Marnie only watched as the hazing unfolded.

The school suspended the girl after telling Leslie Holz that her daughter was involved in a "secret society" and hazing.

A criminal probe is ongoing.

Contributing: Lucio Guerrero and Ana Mendieta.

About half of all U.S. colleges require incoming students to tell them about any serious trouble they've gotten into since they filled out their applications, including the University of Illinois, where, according to the high school's Web site, 174 Glenbrook North current seniors have enrolled.

"There's a committee that evaluates each case," Robin Kaler, a spokesperson at the University's Urbana-Champaign campus, said Monday. "They look at each report individually to determine whether the student might pose a clear and present danger to other students here. If the answer is 'yes,' they recommend to the director of admissions that our offer be rescinded."

It's very likely, admissions experts said, the suspended Glenbrook North seniors will face additional questions, and possibly disciplinary sanctions, from the colleges and universities they'd planned to attend.

"Their admission could be revoked," said J.P. Allen, president of My Footpath, a Chicago firm that offers counseling and coaching services for high school students applying to highly competitive colleges. "At the very least, colleges are going to look twice. They all reserve the right to change their minds based on a student's performance senior year."

High school seniors who have been admitted to the University of Illinois and who have written back agreeing to enroll there are already subject to the school's disciplinary code, Kaler said. Under this code, she said, "students who have been caught hazing on our campus have, at times, been separated from the university." It's also possible, Kaler said, that students involved in violent incidents like the one May 4 at Chipilly Woods forest preserve near Northbrook "might have to agree to special conditions" before being allowed to attend the University of Illinois.

"They might have to take a violence-prevention course," she said, "or might not be allowed to live in a dormitory."

At Northwestern University, admissions officers send a form to high school guidance counselors each spring, asking them to report any "significant changes" in an accepted student's performance or behavior. The reports are evaluated by the admissions office on a case-by-case basis and could trigger responses ranging from no action to a retraction of admission. Northwestern, where 81 Glenbrook North seniors have enrolled, according to the high school's Web site, does not give a specific definition of what must be reported, said spokesman Charles Loebbaka, so it's not clear that the Glenbrook High School administrators would have to report a student's involvement in the violence in the forest preserve.

Harvard--where two Glenbrook North seniors have enrolled--requires applicants and their high schools to report all "changes of status," including suspensions or expulsions. Each case is reviewed by the university's admissions committee, Marlyn McGrath Lewis, Harvard College's admissions director, said Monday, adding, "We are not reluctant to withdraw the offer of admission." Harvard does just that in a handful of cases "every year," Lewis said. "Physical violence, or serious harassment, this would be a great concern to us."



Back to DA*DI's Home

Dads Against the Divorce Industry Dads Against the Divorce Industry